Friday, February 4, 2011

Why blogging is good for the classroom. Essential question #1

     I've heard of blogs before.  They are websites for people with a lot of time on their hands and have a lot opinions.  That was what I used to think.  Blogging is difficult.  Having something of value to share with a community of say, 1 billion people.  That is a lot of pressure.  I now look at blogging like a party.  There are a lot of people with a lot of expertise from a lot of different places.  The interesting part of this party is that we are faceless and nameless if we so choose.  I might say things here that would never be said to a person's face nor to a large audience.  Having said all that, what is the benefit to teachers and students using blogs in a classroom?
     First, students engaging in the blogosphere should be motivated to think and write well.  You cant show up to a party poorly dressed.  Therefore, the choices of words, clarity of points and research must be done with excellence.  The benefit to the student is that they can not hide on a blog.  For example, if a student bombs a test, the only people in the room who know are the teacher and the student.  If a student does a poor job answering a question on a blog, we can reasonably say that most people in the class will know.  I believe that this will motivate the student to put forth effort in bringing ideas together in a clear and meaningful way.  Now, you could argue that this could embarrass a student.  Imagine the same student failing a test and the teacher announcing it to the class.  A poor performance on something so public as a blog could provide the same results as a failing grade being announced.  But, for all you behaviorists out there, negative reinforcement should motivate a student toward a desirable result.  Think and write well.
     Next, blogs are a highly social learning environments that remove social barriers.  When a teacher breaks students up into groups there are many factors that can shape the group dynamic.  Theres usually the talker, the shy one, the doer and the kid who doesn't do anything and waits on the "smart" kids to do the work for them.  Low self-esteem, popularity, crushes (depending on the age group) and kids just not liking each other prevent learning and genuine dialogue on a given topic.  The blogs limit those barriers.  Students can feel free to read and respond without too much worry about the aforementioned barriers.  If your like me, after being in a serious discussion with someone or a group, reflected upon the discussion and thought of a really good point but missed your chance.  If you know what I mean, than blogs provide the opportunity for discussion to take place over a longer period that allow points and disagreements to be fleshed out entirely.  Blogs are very social vehicles for learning that limit social barriers and promote learning.
     Finally, blogs benefit teachers by freeing them from being lecturers and acting more like facilitators.  Lecturing is a one way conversation.  By lecturing and then asking students to blog about the lecture furthers the points made in a lecture but now in a class of say 20 students there are potentially hundreds of conversations going on.  Peer to peer learning is taking place and all this is happening under the facilitators eye.  Bringing back my initial point, students should be motivated think and write well should at the very least regurgitate what they have heard.  But, if you have ever played telephone, you know that everyone hears things differently.  This is a further benefit to the teacher.  If all the blog posts by students miss the key elements of a lecture, what better way for the teacher to know and correct misinformation?  This is a great way for teachers to get feedback without actually asking for it.
     Blogs are great tools for students and teachers alike.  They are by no means only for the opinionated adults with free time.  They are serious avenues of learning.  They demand well thought out points, sharpen writing skills, limit social barriers and help teachers guide rather than lecture.

6 comments:

  1. Hey John,

    I had not thought about of blogs as an evaluation tool. You could ask students to blog about the lesson they learned today and you can get that sense of what went wrong with the lesson or what needs to be reinforced or emphasized or retaught. I really hope we wouldn't have students regurgitating information, but more so being able to formulate thoughts and write comprehensive entries based on reading, research, or learning.

    I think too it is important that we set clear expectations of how blog entries should look because I fear it has become to easy for students to get into "online mode" and start typing without punctuation, or in "lol"s and "brb"s. Rubrics I feel are extremely useful in evaluating students' blog entries.

    Thanks,
    Sean

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Jon,

    This was a great post. It was well thought out and you make great points about the use of blogging in a classroom. I completely agree with your second point that blogs provide opportunities for students to continue a conversation outside the classroom or to simply have their voices heard. Blogging reaches students who normally do not want to talk in class and rather share their thoughts by writing. It's a powerful reflection tool.

    Stephanie

    ReplyDelete
  3. Very well said Jon. Blogs can serve as a tool of expression for many students. Students who are quiet and not participate because the 'loud' already said everything would get a chance to say what they wanted to say the entire 35-40 minutes of class but couldn't. Which leads me to another point, blogging as you said extends the class time. I mean in a classroom, most of the time, so much time is wasted that the time wasted could be recover in blogging. By the time kids get settled in, look for their work due, hand it in, ask their questions about, you do a lesson, but have to end a bit early before the bell rings to make sure that everybody writes their homework down, when is there suppose to be time for everybody to participate. Blogging gets those comments, questions, and misunderstandings out. I liked your post, very well written.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dear Jon,

    I appreciate your analysis of the inter-personal aspects of blogging. I am particularly fond of your illustration of the social experience of having the perfect commentary...well after the conversation has ended. It is true that blogging is a cure for this. I can think of several students from my high school (during the pre-blogging era) who were socially intimidated to raise their hands but who were excellent writers and would have thrived with a format like blogging.
    That being said, your post has also compelled me to visualize more vividly the weak writer. Although there is plenty of research to support that writing makes one a better writer - we must acknowledge that writing can be a very painful process for the struggling student. Here we recognize the benefit of the "student-teacher confidentiality" that is the standard in schools. We know cyber-bullying is a real problem in our schools. How will other students react to a post from a weak student with poor writing or underdeveloped ideas?
    -Amy

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi John!
    I like this idea of blogging as a party - an interesting notion that I think is pretty spot on.

    If I think about my own blogging past I've spent my times locked in a more socially connected blogosphere where sharing was among artists through images rather than words. Now stepping into this written blog party I can definitely feel a new pep in my step and amped feelings in my belly to get things right, to select the right words instead of the right shoes ;)

    I think this kind of challenge is one that will be equally as important for our students. They definitely take the time to choose their shoes in the morning (my third grader filling me in just the other day that she chose to wear her brother's Air Jordan's because they matched her outfit better than her own) and will obviously spend less time on their word choices during our writer's workshop (the same student claims she is finished with her day's work within 5 minutes of our independent process time).

    Setting up a writing world where our kids are no longer writing for their teacher - because, let's face it, they are - they can write for more.

    One thing we will have to ensure though is that we are creating a bloggosphere that is as safe and comfortable as our own classrooms. I think it will be important for teachers to not only rely on the "negative reinforcement" of sour writing equalling sour comments. I think it will be important to set up a preparedness for the outside world commenting and what may come of it and how to handle it.

    Blog On-
    Hannah

    ReplyDelete